I’ve worked with many gym owners who started with Concept2 rowers and came back asking for something fresh for their members. They liked reliability but wanted machines that stood out and gave clients a different feel.
If that sounds familiar, you’re not alone. Many commercial gyms are looking at new options that can match Concept2’s strength while offering a new experience.
I’ve tested commercial-grade rowers for years. My job is to help fitness businesses choose equipment that lasts, attracts clients, and fits their space and budget. The reviews I share come from hands-on use and real gym feedback.
In this article, you’ll see how WaterRower, Hydrow, and NordicTrack compare as Concept2 alternatives. You’ll learn how each performs, what features matter for gyms, and which models can work best for your business goals.
If you’ve been wondering which rower to bring into your gym next, you’re in the right place.
Let’s get started!
- 1. Why Look Beyond Concept2?
- 2. Quick Comparison of Concept2 Alternatives
- 3. WaterRower: Best for Natural Feel and Quiet Operation
- 4. Hydrow: Best for Digital Engagement and Immersive Training
- 5. NordicTrack: Best for Smart Features and Cost Efficiency
- 6. Factors to Consider When Choosing a Concept2 Alternative
- 7. Why Not Import From a Chinese Supplier
- Conclusion
1. Why Look Beyond Concept2?
I’ve seen many gyms rely on Concept2 for years, and for good reason. It’s a dependable rower that can handle daily use. But as your gym grows, you start looking at what else can add value for your members. Maybe you want quieter machines, a sleeker look, or more digital features to keep clients engaged.
If that sounds familiar, it might be time to explore other options. Newer rowers bring features that can make a real difference in how your members train and how your gym stands out.
Here are a few reasons why many owners are now exploring Concept2 alternatives:
- Member Experience: Clients expect variety and modern design.
- Aesthetics: Some gyms want equipment that fits their brand look.
- Technology: Smart features and connected workouts are in demand.
- Maintenance: Newer models can offer easier upkeep and quieter use.
- Space Efficiency: Some machines save more floor space than Concept2.
Looking beyond Concept2 doesn’t mean replacing a trusted brand. It means finding what works best for your business today and for the clients you serve every day.
2. Quick Comparison of Concept2 Alternatives
If you’re short on time, here’s a quick side-by-side look at Concept2 and its main competitors. I’ve tested these models in commercial gyms, so this table focuses on what really matters for daily use, maintenance, and member satisfaction.
Before diving in deeper, here’s a quick guide on where each shines:
- WaterRower: Best for gyms that want a natural rowing feel and stylish look.
- Hydrow: Best for facilities focused on digital classes and interactive training.
- NordicTrack: Best for gyms that want a mix of smart features and value pricing.
Brand / Model | Key Features | Strengths | Drawbacks |
Concept2 RowErg | Accurate PM5 monitor, adjustable airflow | Proven durability, trusted in gyms worldwide | Louder fan noise, no built-in screen |
WaterRower | Water tank resistance, handcrafted wood frame | Natural feel, quiet operation, premium look | Requires refilling and cleaning water tank |
Hydrow | HD touchscreen, live/on-demand classes | Immersive workouts, smooth resistance, quiet | High cost, app subscription required |
NordicTrack RW900 | 22” HD touchscreen, iFit workouts | Balanced resistance, engaging content, good value | Needs iFit subscription, heavier build |
Each of these rowers has its strengths. The right one for your gym depends on your training goals, your space, and the experience you want to offer your members.
3. WaterRower: Best for Natural Feel and Quiet Operation
Many gym owners choose the WaterRower for its quiet operation and smooth feel. It’s built for those who value design as much as performance. If your clients appreciate a natural rowing experience, this machine delivers that calm, water-based resistance that feels close to real rowing.
Strengths
- Natural Feel and Resistance: The WaterRower uses real water for resistance, giving a smooth and consistent pull that mimics rowing on a river. Members often find this more engaging and enjoyable than air resistance.
- Low Noise Operation: It’s one of the quietest rowers available. The water sound is soft and pleasant, making it suitable for studios where noise control and member experience matter.
- Premium Design: Built with handcrafted wood, it brings warmth and elegance to your gym. It blends into both luxury fitness gyms and wellness-focused spaces, adding visual appeal.
- Durability and Comfort: Though elegant, it’s also built to last. The frame holds up well under daily commercial use, and the seat and handle are comfortable for longer training sessions.
Weaknesses
- Higher Maintenance Needs: The water tank needs occasional cleaning and refilling. It’s not complicated, but it does require a bit more attention than air or magnetic models.
- Limited Tech Features: The monitor provides basic performance data but lacks advanced metrics or guided training options. Tech-focused gyms may find this limiting.
- Heavier Frame: The solid wood frame looks great but adds weight. Moving or repositioning the machine can be harder in busy commercial setups.
- Smaller Market for Parts: Replacement parts and accessories may take longer to source compared to more common commercial brands like Concept2.
Why Gym Owners and Users Like This Brand
Gym owners often tell me their clients are drawn to the WaterRower because of its look and feel. It creates a quiet and calm environment, which suits studios focused on premium training experiences. Members also say the sound of the water helps them relax and stay consistent during workouts. For gyms that want both performance and design, the WaterRower checks both boxes.
4. Hydrow: Best for Digital Engagement and Immersive Training
Hydrow has become one of the most talked-about options among gym owners upgrading their rowing lineup. It blends smooth magnetic resistance with digital features that keep members coming back. If your clients enjoy guided classes or visual workouts, this machine fits right in.
Strengths
- Immersive Digital Training: Hydrow offers live and on-demand workouts through its large HD screen. Members can row alongside real instructors and track their progress in real time, which adds motivation and variety to each session.
- Quiet Magnetic Resistance: The magnetic resistance system is nearly silent, making it perfect for gyms that host multiple classes or personal training sessions in one space.
- Modern and Durable Build: Its aluminum frame looks sleek but also stands up well under heavy commercial use. The glide is smooth and consistent, ideal for both short bursts and long endurance work.
- Strong Member Engagement: Hydrow’s interactive setup encourages clients to train more often. The visuals and feedback system help users feel part of a community, which supports long-term member retention.
Weaknesses
- Subscription Cost: Access to classes and digital features requires a monthly subscription. This adds to the ongoing cost for gyms that want to give members full access.
- Higher Upfront Price: Hydrow comes at a premium price compared to most commercial rowers. For smaller gyms, it might be hard to justify multiple units at once.
- Heavy and Less Mobile: The machine is solid but not easy to move. It takes planning to position it properly in your gym layout.
- Limited Customization: Unlike other rowers, Hydrow’s resistance settings are automated. Some athletes may prefer more manual control during strength or interval sessions.
Why Gym Owners and Users Like This Brand
Gym owners tell me that Hydrow helps them keep clients engaged longer. The classes give structure to rowing workouts, which many members find motivating. Users love the visual element—rowing through scenic waters on screen makes sessions more enjoyable. For facilities that focus on digital or community-based fitness, Hydrow fits that model well.
5. NordicTrack: Best for Smart Features and Cost Efficiency
NordicTrack has earned its place in many gyms as a solid, tech-ready rower that doesn’t stretch the budget. It gives your members digital workouts and adjustable resistance without the high cost of some premium models. If you’re running a mid-size gym, this one’s worth a close look.
Strengths
- Good Balance of Cost and Features: NordicTrack offers an HD touchscreen and magnetic resistance at a reasonable price. You get access to interactive training without paying top-tier costs.
- Integrated iFit Training: The built-in iFit platform adds variety to workouts, giving your members on-demand and instructor-led options that boost engagement and consistency.
- Adjustable Resistance System: The combination of air and magnetic resistance makes it flexible for both beginners and experienced rowers. This helps trainers adjust sessions easily for different fitness levels.
- Compact and Easy to Store: Its foldable design is practical for gyms with limited floor space. Moving and storing the unit is manageable, even for small facilities.
Weaknesses
- Subscription-Dependent Experience: The iFit program requires a subscription to unlock its best content. Without it, members get fewer features and less motivation from guided workouts.
- Build Quality Slightly Lower Than Premium Models: The frame is sturdy, but not as heavy-duty as Hydrow or Concept2. It’s best suited for medium traffic rather than high-intensity commercial environments.
- Limited Custom Settings: Trainers who want full control over metrics or resistance fine-tuning may find it restrictive compared to Concept2’s open system.
- Heavier Screen Unit: The touchscreen adds bulk, making the upper section less sleek and a bit harder to reposition.
Why Gym Owners and Users Like This Brand
Gym owners appreciate that NordicTrack gives strong performance for its cost. It’s a good fit for gyms that want technology and variety without overspending. Members enjoy the visual workouts, clean design, and smooth feel. For growing gyms, it’s often a practical upgrade that adds value without major financial strain.
6. Factors to Consider When Choosing a Concept2 Alternative
Finding the right rowing machine for your gym means thinking beyond brand names. You want equipment that fits your members, your layout, and your business goals. After working with many gym owners, I’ve found that the best choices come down to the main factors.
Training Goals and Member Type
Start by thinking about who uses your gym. Are your members focused on conditioning, endurance, or general fitness? Concept2 rowers are great for athletes and competitive users, but alternatives like WaterRower or Hydrow may fit better for clients who value comfort and engagement.
The right rower should match your training style—whether it’s high-intensity circuits or calm endurance sessions. Choosing based on member habits helps ensure your investment actually supports how people train.
Technology and Engagement
Technology is now part of how members experience workouts. Many clients look for screens, coaching apps, or connected performance tracking. Hydrow and NordicTrack offer these features through digital memberships, giving your gym a modern edge.
But if you prefer straightforward machines that don’t rely on software updates or subscriptions, Concept2 and WaterRower still deliver strong results. Decide what kind of experience you want to offer before buying.
Space and Noise Control
Your gym layout and environment play a big role in the right pick. Some rowers, like Concept2, take more space and produce more sound, which can be an issue in smaller gyms or studios. Magnetic and water models are much quieter and blend better in shared workout areas.
Always test where the machines will go and how they’ll sound during peak hours. Small layout adjustments can make your gym feel more open and inviting.
7. Why Not Import From a Chinese Supplier
Many gym owners start exploring Concept2 alternatives and soon wonder if importing directly from China could save money. It’s a fair thought, China produces a massive share of the world’s fitness equipment, and some factories promise low prices and fast delivery.
But choosing the right supplier makes all the difference. If quality, reliability, and long-term performance matter to you, not all manufacturers meet those standards.
That’s where YR Fitness stands out. I’ve worked with gym owners who found the right balance of cost and quality through them. They’re not the cheapest, but they build equipment meant for daily commercial use—strong, safe, and made to last.
Here’s what makes YR Fitness worth your attention:
- Commercial-Grade Engineering: Built with heavy-duty frames and tested angles that support professional training in busy gym settings.
- Long-Term Durability: Designed to handle years of continuous use, with many gyms using their machines for eight years or more.
- Global Trust and Recognition: Used by large gym chains and organizations worldwide, including the American Army and major fitness networks.
- Reliable Support and Delivery: Fast logistics, assured after-sales service, and responsive communication before and after purchase keep operations smooth.
If you’re comparing Concept2 alternatives and want commercial-level quality without inflated costs, YR Fitness is a reliable partner to consider.
Recommended Reading:
If you’re researching reliable suppliers and want a clearer view of today’s best manufacturers, don’t miss this helpful roundup:
Conclusion
You’ve seen how WaterRower, Hydrow, and NordicTrack stack up against the Concept2. Each can work, but the right choice depends on your gym’s space, members, and budget.
I’ve seen owners who choose well grow faster because their equipment keeps clients coming back. As you plan your next upgrade, think long-term, not just about the next few months.
YR Fitness builds commercial machines that deliver steady results and dependable performance. Visit their site today to discuss what setup will help your gym reach the next level.
Related articles:
